1 Lon L Fuller, `The Case of the Speluncean Explorers’ 2 See, eg, Jordi Ferrer Beltr n and Giovanni Battista Ratti (eds), The Logic of Legal Requirements. articles were Henry Hart’s famous dialogue2 and Lon Fuller’s presen- tation of the case of the speluncean explorers.3 They still are. Why is that so? Perhaps one. Tags: legal theory, judicial decisions, Speluncean Explorers . the force of legal theories in action is Lon Fuller’s The Case of the Speluncean

Author: Vudoshakar Douran
Country: Lithuania
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Relationship
Published (Last): 10 November 2016
Pages: 312
PDF File Size: 4.36 Mb
ePub File Size: 7.74 Mb
ISBN: 156-1-41642-867-7
Downloads: 11777
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Maukinos

As the Court’s decision is a tie, the original convictions are upheld and the men are sentenced to death. George Washington Law Review.

Justice Keen objects vehemently to Justice Foster’s purposive approach allowing the plain words of the law to be ignored. Fuller first published in the Harvard Law Review in The Case for Phenomenal Externalism. Explordrs decide to engage in cannibalismand select one of their number to be killed and eaten so that the others may survive.

The Case of the Speluncean Explorers – Wikipedia

East Dane Designer Men’s Fashion. Wikipedia articles needing clarification from March Although the wording of the statute is clear and unambiguous, there is intense public pressure for the men to avoid facing the death penalty.

Sign in Create an account. If their appeal to the Supreme Court of Newgarth fails, they face a mandatory death sentence. I’d like to read this book on Kindle Don’t have a Kindle? Whetmore then asks if they should draw lots fuoler select a person to be killed and eaten. Amazon Restaurants Food delivery from local restaurants. The cavers are ultimately exploregs of murder.

Criticises Chief Justice’s proposed appeal to Executive for clemency given need to respect separation of powers ; should only make appeal in capacity as private citizens Moral considerations are irrelevant in applying the statute.


Share your thoughts with other loj.

In the third opinion, Justice Tatting is emotionally “torn between sympathy for [the defendants] and a feeling of abhorrence and disgust at the monstrous act they committed”. Radio contact is eventually established with the cavers on the 20th day of the cave-in, and the cavers learn that another 10 days would be required in order to free them.

William Calder Iii – unknown – Arion 9 2. Sign in to use this feature. Amazon Renewed Refurbished products with a warranty. No one outside the cave is willing to answer this question. Write a customer review. Radio contact is subsequently lost.

The Case of the Speluncean Explorers

This would allow justice to be achieved “without impairing either the letter or spirit of our statutes and without offering any explorees for the disregard of law”. Retrieved from ” https: Fuller’s account has been described as “a classic in jurisprudence ” [2] and “a microcosm of [the 20th] century’s debates” in legal philosophy.

The survivors state that Whetmore had originally come up with the ideas of cannibalism and choosing the victim through random chance, offering a pair of dice in his possession. Product details Pamphlet Publisher: He draws analogies to servants who need to “read between the lines” of their masters’ instructions; strict literal compliance may not always be the actual intention.

The judge cites the case of Commonwealth v Valjean[b] in which starvation was speluncewn not to justify the theft of a loaf of bread, let alone homicide.

The judge counters potential objections of judicial activism by suggesting that although judges must obey the will of legislators, they must do so intelligently. History of Western Philosophy. There’s a problem loading this menu right now. Request removal from index.

This article has no associated abstract. They learn via intermittent radio contact that, without food, they are likely to starve to death before they can be rescued. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. The case involves spelluncean explorers who are caved in following a landslide. Science Logic and Mathematics.



Feteris – – Argumentation 19 4: In the 50 years following the article’s publication, a further 25 hypothetical judgments were written by various authors whose perspectives include natural law theory, consequentialismplain meaning speluuncean or textualismpurposivism, historical contextualism, realism, pragmatism, critical legal studiesfeminismcritical race theoryprocess theory and minimalism. Five cave explorers became trapped inside a cave following a landslide.

English Choose a language for speluncexn. Criticises Foster J’s approach The natural law under the posited “state of nature” prioritises freedom of contract above the right to life Purposive approach to statutory interpretation is difficult when there are multiple purposes here, retribution and rehabilitation Cannot decide case due to competing legal rationales and emotions.

Withoutabox Submit to Film Festivals. George Dumezil and Mircea Eliade]. Amazon Rapids Fun stories for kids on the go. In contrast to the other judges, Justice Handy prefers to use a “pragmatic, common-sense approach”, rather than explorere legal theories, to resolve the case. Harvard Law Review Cohen – – Isis: Judges can find an exception to the law by implication, as the Courts had earlier done with self-defense.

Despite rejecting Justice Foster’s reasoning, Justice Tatting spelunceean bring himself to reach the alternative view, that the defendants’ convictions should be upheld. The medical experts reluctantly fxplorers this to be the case. Learn more about Amazon Prime.